Checks In The Mail Return Policy
Every return window, fee, and holiday extension for Checks In The Mail — pulled from the retailer's own policy page and linked below so you can confirm it yourself.
This is a print-on-demand personalized product, so there is no standard return/refund path - if checks arrive wrong, your only recourse is to contact customer service and request a free replacement for their error, not a refund; you also have just a 15-minute window after ordering to call and cancel or change the order before it enters production.
Policy at a glance
- Return window
- 0 days (personalized checks are non-returnable; replacement only for company errors)
- Free returns
- No
- Category
- General
Can’t be returned: Personalized/custom-printed checks and check accessories once produced
Why Checks In The Mail earned a C-
How Checks In The Mail compares
Top-graded General rivals — tap one for the full side-by-side.
About Checks In The Mail
Checks In The Mail does exactly what the name says — personal and business checks, printed to order, in everything from plain classic designs to licensed prints featuring Peanuts, Star Wars, or the ASPCA. Beyond the checks themselves, they sell the accessories that go with them: checkbook covers, address labels, deposit supplies, and security stamps.
Because checks are personalized with your name and account info the moment you order them, they can't really be returned or resold once printed — that's the caveat here, so double-check your account and routing numbers before submitting. Reordering is quick once your info is saved, which matters if you're a repeat business customer. This is a practical purchase rather than an exciting one: you're here because you still write checks and want a design you don't hate.
What they sell
- Personal checks in classic and licensed character designs
- Business and computer checks
- Checkbook covers and registers
- Address labels and stamps
- Deposit slips and tax forms
Frequently asked questions
What is Checks In The Mail's return window?
0 days (personalized checks are non-returnable; replacement only for company errors)
Does Checks In The Mail offer free returns?
No
What items cannot be returned to Checks In The Mail?
Personalized/custom-printed checks and check accessories once produced
Also known as
checksinthemail.com, checks in the mail, citm
Return-policy data is compiled from Checks In The Mail’s public customer-service pages by Thrifle AI, our in-house research system. Policies change often and we can be out of date — always confirm on Checks In The Mail’s official site before purchase. Spotted something wrong? Tell usand we’ll fix it.